Litterae
From Digressio Vol. 3Faith and Reason, Story and Theology in Tolkien and St. Anselm
Anselm’s “faith seeking understanding” and Tolkien’s account of how a reader enters a story describe the same movement.
At the end of the first chapter of his delightful and challenging little work the Proslogion, St. Anselm of Canterbury (1033–1109) explains his famous maxim of fides quaerens intellectum, or “faith seeking understanding.” He exclaims in a prayer lifted up to God that “I do not seek to understand in order to believe, but I believe in order to understand. For I believe even this: that unless I believe, I shall not understand.” While Anselm believed, on the one hand, in what he referred to as the ratio fidei, or the “rationality” or “intelligibility” of the Christian faith, such that possessing a well-reasoned, philosophical understanding of Christian truth was not only possible but exceedingly desirable, he believed, on the other hand, that this same understanding was impossible unless one’s reason was first grounded in and guided by a simple, trusting faith in God and in his Word.
The great twentieth-century fantasy author J. R. R. Tolkien had in mind, or so I want to begin by suggesting here, a related view of the relationship of faith and reason that in his account of how we are to engage with the realities not only of divine, but also of human making. In his well-known essay “On Fairy-Stories,” Tolkien explains how, in the proper experience of a story, the reader or hearer enters into the subcreated “Secondary World” through an act of what Tolkien variously refers to as “literary” and “Secondary Belief.” “What really happens,” he writes in one passage, “is that the story-maker proves a successful ‘sub-creator.’ He makes a Secondary World which your mind can enter. Inside it, what he relates is ‘true’: it accords with the laws of that world. You therefore believe it, while you are, as it were, inside.” In other words, when we read or hear a story, we are implicitly consenting to accept the world of that story on its own terms, as we say. Put differently, hearing or reading a story is—or at least ought to be—an act of good faith, an act, that is, whereby we pledge our sincere intention to receive the storyteller’s world and its truths for what they are.
If a reader is to enter a story by faith, the author has the reciprocal duty of crafting a story that allows this literary faith to be led to understanding.
Dr. Jonathan McIntosh
If a reader is to enter a story by faith, however, as Tolkien also makes clear, the author has the reciprocal duty of crafting a story that allows this literary faith to be led to understanding, of making a world in which (as Tolkien put it above) the rational “mind can enter.” Elsewhere in his essay Tolkien describes this duty in terms of the author imbuing his story with the “inner consistency of reality,” a task that he says is, by its very nature, especially difficult for, though no less incumbent upon, the author of fantasy or fairy stories. He gives the example of the fantastical image of a “green sun,” which he says is relatively easy to say or to imagine, but “[t]o make a Secondary World inside which the green sun will be credible, commanding Secondary Belief, will probably require labour and thought, and will certainly demand a special skill, a kind of elvish craft.” A world deserving of belief, in other words, will only be a rational or internally consistent world, satisfying both faith and reason. It is for this reason, Tolkien declares, that fantasy in particular “certainly does not destroy or even insult Reason; and it does not either blunt the appetite for, nor obscure the perception of, scientific verity. On the contrary. The keener and the clearer is the reason, the better fantasy will it make.” The literary faith that all good stories seek to court, Tolkien implies, is also an Anselmian faith, a faith that desires, seeks, and must ultimately receive understanding of the things and world(s) which it believes.
Our reading of stories is to practice the faith-leading-to-understanding process by which we are to read the “story” of God’s own acts of creation and redemption.
Dr. Jonathan McIntosh
Our reading of stories, then, is not only to mirror, but by mirroring, also to practice, the faith-leading-to-understanding process by which, at least according to Anselm, we are to read the “story” of God’s own acts of creation and redemption. But if so, then we might expect the reverse also to hold true: that there is something inevitably storylike, even “subcreational,” in our otherwise theological study of the Christian faith and its objective truth. Returning once again to the example of Anselm, significantly enough, this is exactly what we do find. In his first major theological work, the Monologion, for example, Anselm attempts to rationally demonstrate God’s existence, essence, and attributes, yet he also cautions his reader that “if in this investigation I say something that a greater authority does not teach, I want it to be accepted in such way that even if it is a necessary consequence of reasons which will seem good to me, it is not thereby said to be absolutely necessary, but is said only to be able to appear necessary for the time being.” In other words, although he is confident that his faith-inflected reason is able to demonstrate the rationality—or the “inner consistency,” to use Tolkien’s expression—of the objective, primary world as taught within the Christian faith, Anselm is at the same time aware that his arguments for this reality are nevertheless his arguments, and as such are things “made” by him. In Anselm, in sum, we see theology presented as a form of subcreation: our arguments explaining the faith represent a kind of theological “story” that one must enter into through an act of good faith, a story that, while there, promises to also satisfy our reason as it seeks to mirror the consistency of God’s own reality, yet a story that, for all its rationality, remains a story, for it is ultimately about a reality that is not of its own making.
Another, final example in Anselm’s thought of this Tolkienian theme of theology-as-story may be found again in the Proslogion. In his preface to the piece, Anselm indicates that the following prayer is actually not written in his own voice or from precisely his own perspective, but is rather written “in the role”—sub persona in Latin—“of someone seeking to understand what he believes.” The Proslogion, in other words, while a theological prayer and serious meditation on the nature of God, is also a story whose main character, while obviously related to and reflective of Anselm’s own experience, is at the same time also a creature of Anselm’s own invention, and therefore one whose story Anselm would have us enter into with the same kind of faith modeled by his fictional persona.
What is more, in keeping with the subcreated nature of the Proslogion’s protagonist is the remarkably dramatic character and arc of its central argument, as Anselm invites his reader not only to follow along with, but indeed to participate in the radical transformation that his alter ego undergoes over the course of the work. For although Anselm’s persona begins, as was noted above, in faith, his faith in this case happens to be a quite despondent and forlorn faith, as it longs to experience directly God’s presence but instead, due to his sin and creaturely finitude, feels only His absence. (Anselm, interestingly and amusingly, goes so far as to address his fictive self as a homuncio, meaning “little man” or even “manikin”—or, as Tolkien might have it, “Hobbit.”)
By the end of the Proslogion, however, a drastic change has occurred, one best described, once again, in Tolkienian categories, though this time in terms of what Tolkien famously refers to in his essay as “eucatastrophe”—i.e., that unlooked-for, “sudden joyous turn” of the happy ending which recurs throughout history in our fairy stories but in which is prefigured or foreshadowed, according to Tolkien, the great Eucatastrophe that was the Incarnation, Death, and Resurrection of Jesus Christ. In the case of the Proslogion, the eucatastrophic turn and thrill to which Anselm aims to treat his own readers occurs at the end when, in the final chapters of his journey of faith seeking understanding, and with the word joy appearing some thirty-five times, his persona at last discovers that the God he sought is, in the words of one admirer Tolkien once quoted to describe the theology of The Lord of the Rings, “that one ever-present Person who is never absent and never named” (Letters).
To conclude, then, we have seen how St. Anselm of Canterbury’s famous theological program of faith seeking rational understanding parallels J. R. R. Tolkien’s own account of how our stories are things which, on the one hand, must be received and entered into in trusting belief, but, on the other hand, must sustain and nurture that belief by exhibiting the same kind of inner consistency and rationality as the real world. If Tolkien is right, however, and Anselm’s real-world understanding of the relationship of faith and reason is to be reflected in the world of story, then, as I have further suggested, we shouldn’t be surprised to find the real-world relationship of faith and reason imitating something of the character with which we engage with the secondary worlds of our stories. And in the case of Anselm, at least, I have suggested that this is in fact what we do find: first, in how Anselm represents his own theology as something at once striving after a truth that is objective, independent, and indeed, ultimate, but also limited, provisional, and tentative—in a word, subcreated; second, in Anselm’s personification and dramatization of his argument of the Proslogion in terms of a humble, even Hobbitic inquirer who experiences a eucatastrophe of theological discovery. Indeed, in Anselm’s Proslogion, finally, we witness a form of theology, not only as story, but more specifically, as a veritable fairy story, as Anselm sets out to re-create for us within his theological argument the very experience of gospel sorrow-turned-to-joy that lies at the heart of all theology and of every fairy story.
Works Cited
Anselm, Monologion 1, in Complete Philosophical and Theological Treatises of Anselm of Canterbury, trans. Jasper Hopkins and Herbert Richardson (Arthur J. Banning, 2000). ——————, Proslogion 1, in Complete Philosophical and Theological Treatises of Anselm of Canterbury, trans. Jasper Hopkins and Herbert Richardson (Arthur J. Banning, 2000).
J. R. R. Tolkien, “On Fairy-Stories,” in Tree and Leaf: Including Mythopoeia (Harper Collins, 2001).
——————, Letters of J. R. R. Tolkien, ed. Humphrey Carpenter (Houghton Mifflin, 1981), 253.
Topics DigressioGreat Books